Saturday, October 3, 2009

The great Indian herd mentality

Written on 2009.10.02

As I start typing this, I know I am going to make a few more enemies by the end of it. But do I really care? Yup, you guessed right.... No! Let me give you the background on this.

A long time ago, I read it in one of my favourite automags. It stated that people from the "bimaru" states (namely Bihar, Madhyapradesh, Rajasthan, Uttarpradesh) have a herd mentality. It means that they share similar behaviour, opinions and goals. So far, so good. But the trouble is, when the herd meets someone from outside their territory. They realise that this person has many things which are different from them. To their horror, they also realise that some of the ideas and abilities that the other person has, are something none amongst them possess.

They choose between two simple options:
(1) Make themselves and everyone else believe that they themselves are better.
(2) Hate the other person, insult them and try to make them believe they are worse.

This I have seen in most of the Northies I know, and it is something I have come to accept as a part of their character. But I got to know their true level of thick-headedness after coming to Japan. Let me describe my experiences to you.

Their strong beliefs are:
(1) If a meal does not have roti, dal, paneer, sabji, raita and dahi, it is not a meal.
(2) If someone eats beef or pork, they are worse than animals.
(3) Unless you stay in groups, talk and laugh very loudly, offend everyone around you, you are not having fun.
(4) Everyone knows Hindi. South Indians who cannot speak Hindi are illiterate idiots.
(5) Everyone is updated about the latest Bollywood movies and songs.
(6) If you have to enjoy listening to your music, you have to play it so loud that everyone in the neighbourhood can also enjoy it.
(7) Those who don't join IITs, IIMs, AIIMS, the Civil Services or go to the US of A, are total failures.
(8) Your success can ONLY be measured by the amount of money you have gathered.
(9) Even English has to be spoken in Hindi (get it?).
(10) Every Japanese restaurant and canteen should always have steaming hot, tasty Indian food available.
(11) It is their birth-right to not follow any of the manners or discipline in any other country. India is the world to them.
(12) If you are tolerant to anyone from outside your region, you are weird.
(13) If it is not like this in India, why is it so in Japan? I will not do it.
(14) We know what South girls actually are.

Now that I have made enemies of all my Northie friends, let me make some from the South too.
Their strong beliefs include:
(1) Hindi is not our national language and everyone should know English.
(2) Even if I have to live in North India for 10 years, my vocabulary would not go past 20 words, all misused, abused and misunderstood.
(3) Rice is the only edible thing in this world and we have to eat it morning till night (including dosas and idlis).
(4) We are much more intelligent than those up North, although we rarely feature in any top-ranks of the Civil Services Examination.
(5) I will speak my limited Hindi vocabulary in my own peculiar South-Indian accent and everyone will understand exactly what I am trying to say.
(6) I don't know what paneer or kheer is.
(7) If it is not like this in India, why is it so in Japan? I will not do it.
(8) We know what North girls actually are.

I lived down South for 26 years, in the centre for 6 months and up North for 1.5 years. Believe me, if you try hard enough, you can be happy anywhere. Even out here in a country where they don't speak English, Hindi or any of your South Indian languages. It all depends on your mindset.

No comments: